Monday, February 21, 2011

The Problem with Pragmatism

A preacher friend of mine once remarked tongue in cheek, “the problem with pragmatism is, it works.” And in today’s culture of self absorption something is only good if it works for you; “works for me” as the saying goes. Anyway, pragmatism is the philosophy that something is true and good only if it produces the desired results. It’s take a bit of discernment to see the danger of such an anti-biblical approach to life. I’ve heard people say they left the church because it just wasn’t working for them. A young woman recently told me of her separation from her husband saying it just didn’t work. I mean, heaven forbid, we put up with someone or some thing that doesn’t make life better for us. Isn’t it Dr. Phil who always asks, “how’s that workin’ for ya?”
When it comes to church it’s easy to get caught up with what works even though it may not reflect sound Biblical methodology. Of course, I’m coming from the position that scripture informs both our message and our methodology. At the same time, I am not adverse to trying new methods. I agree with the old adage; “methods are many, principles are few, methods may change, principles never do.” My contention is this: are we giving in to a culture that dictates how we do ministry before analyzing it in light of scripture? I went to a church website recently and the last few sermon series were take-offs on TV shows or popular movies. I thought maybe I should do a series on “Desperate Housewives”; that’s a catchy title. Maybe even post a few graphics with forlorn looking hotties to advertise it all. Throw in a few video clips that may be a hint suggestive and people will surely be impressed. I mean, after all, it apparently works for a lot of churches. I’d rather not.